ReclaimDeposit
Tools
← Back to Guides

What is Normal Wear and Tear?

Understanding the difference between normal wear and tenant damage is crucial for protecting your security deposit. Landlords cannot charge you for normal wear and tear.

8 min read•Last updated: January 2024

Key Points

  • ✓Landlords CANNOT deduct for normal wear and tear - it's built into your rent
  • ✓Length of tenancy matters - longer stays mean more wear is expected
  • ✓Items have limited lifespans - you only pay for remaining useful life
  • ✓Document everything at move-in to prove pre-existing conditions

Understanding Normal Wear and Tear

Normal wear and tear is the natural deterioration that occurs in a rental property over time with ordinary, everyday use. This is an expected part of renting - landlords build the cost of maintenance into the rent you pay each month.

The key distinction is between damage caused by negligence, carelessness, or abuse versus deterioration that happens simply from living in the space normally. A scuff on the wall from a chair? Normal wear. A hole punched in the wall? Tenant damage.

Why This Matters for Your Security Deposit

Security deposits exist to protect landlords from actual damage to their property - not to fund routine maintenance. Every state has laws limiting what landlords can deduct from your deposit, and ALL states prohibit deductions for normal wear and tear.

If your landlord deducts for normal wear and tear, they may be:

  • Required to return those funds
  • Subject to penalty damages (2x-3x in some states)
  • Liable for your court costs and fees

Normal Wear vs. Tenant Damage: Examples

Walls

Normal Wear (NOT Chargeable)

  • ✓Small nail holes from hanging pictures
  • ✓Minor scuffs from furniture
  • ✓Slight fading from sunlight
  • ✓Hairline cracks from settling

Tenant Damage (May Be Chargeable)

  • ✗Large holes requiring patching
  • ✗Crayon, marker, or paint marks
  • ✗Unauthorized painting
  • ✗Gouges or deep scratches

Carpet

Normal Wear (NOT Chargeable)

  • ✓Matting in high-traffic areas
  • ✓Light fading from sunlight
  • ✓Slight wear near doorways
  • ✓Minor indentations from furniture

Tenant Damage (May Be Chargeable)

  • ✗Burns from cigarettes or irons
  • ✗Stains that won't come out
  • ✗Pet urine damage
  • ✗Rips, tears, or cuts

Appliances

Normal Wear (NOT Chargeable)

  • ✓Gradual wear on controls
  • ✓Normal aging of components
  • ✓Minor scratches on surfaces
  • ✓Burned-out light bulbs

Tenant Damage (May Be Chargeable)

  • ✗Broken handles or knobs
  • ✗Cracked glass or doors
  • ✗Damage from misuse
  • ✗Interior stains from neglect

Bathroom

Normal Wear (NOT Chargeable)

  • ✓Worn caulk around tub
  • ✓Minor discoloration of fixtures
  • ✓Faded paint from moisture
  • ✓Normal grout wear

Tenant Damage (May Be Chargeable)

  • ✗Broken toilet seat or tank lid
  • ✗Excessive mold from lack of ventilation
  • ✗Cracked tiles from impact
  • ✗Damaged faucets from misuse

Windows & Doors

Normal Wear (NOT Chargeable)

  • ✓Worn weather stripping
  • ✓Minor scratches on glass
  • ✓Faded paint on frames
  • ✓Sticky locks from age

Tenant Damage (May Be Chargeable)

  • ✗Broken glass or screens
  • ✗Holes in screens
  • ✗Damaged locks or handles
  • ✗Broken blinds from misuse

Important: Depreciation Limits What You Owe

Even if you did cause damage beyond normal wear, you don't necessarily owe the full replacement cost. Items have limited useful lifespans, and you only owe for the remaining value.

5-10 years

Carpet lifespan

3-5 years

Paint lifespan

10-15 years

Appliance lifespan

Example: If a 7-year-old carpet (5-year lifespan) is damaged, the landlord cannot charge you anything - it was already beyond its useful life.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is normal wear and tear?

Normal wear and tear refers to the natural deterioration of a property that occurs over time with ordinary use. It includes things like minor scuffs on walls, carpet matting in high-traffic areas, and gradual fading of paint. Landlords cannot deduct for normal wear and tear.

Can my landlord charge me for painting?

Generally, no. Painting is typically considered routine maintenance that landlords must cover. However, if you painted walls an unauthorized color or caused excessive damage to walls beyond normal wear, you may be charged. Most states require landlords to repaint every few years anyway.

Who decides what is normal wear and tear?

If you and your landlord disagree, ultimately a judge in small claims court makes this determination. Judges typically consider the length of tenancy, the condition at move-in (documented with photos), and whether the damage goes beyond what would reasonably occur with normal use.

Does carpet have a limited lifespan?

Yes. Carpet typically has a useful life of 5-10 years depending on quality. If you lived in a unit for 6 years and the carpet is worn, the landlord cannot charge you full replacement cost. They can only charge for the remaining useful life value, and often nothing at all if the carpet was already old.

Can I be charged for professional cleaning?

Only if the unit is left significantly dirtier than normal. If you leave the unit in reasonably clean condition, landlords cannot charge for professional cleaning just because they prefer it. The standard is whether the unit was left in a condition similar to how you received it (minus normal wear).

Think Your Landlord Charged for Normal Wear?

Use our free tools to analyze your deductions and determine if you can challenge them. Our Wear vs. Damage Guide can help you identify improper charges.