Replacing air filters is often normal property maintenance. A landlord may try to charge for it as a move-out cost, but disputes turn on whether it's routine upkeep versus tenant-caused neglect supported by proof.
When the charge can be legitimate
- Lease clearly assigns filter replacement to tenant and it was neglected
- There's evidence neglect caused additional issues (case-specific)
- The charge reflects actual cost and is documented
Red flags
- Charging for routine maintenance items that landlords replace between tenants anyway
- No lease clause showing tenant responsibility
- Inflated charge for a low-cost item without a receipt
What to ask for
- Lease clause assigning filter responsibility
- Receipt for filter(s) and date of replacement
- Any inspection notes showing neglect or related issues
How to dispute
- Confirm whether the lease actually makes filters your responsibility.
- Request receipts and a breakdown of what was replaced.
- Dispute routine maintenance billed as tenant damage.
Start with the dispute template, then escalate to a demand letter if the landlord won't correct it.
Tip: Use the Deduction Checker to challenge unsupported "maintenance" charges and request the lease clause + receipts.